Ed Sheeran - Perfect -

To understand “Perfect,” one must understand the moment it was released. In 2017, pop music was oscillating between the minimalist trap of Post Malone and the maximalist disco of Dua Lipa. “Perfect” offered a counter-programming: a return to the acoustic, unplugged sincerity of the early 1970s singer-songwriter era (James Taylor, Cat Stevens) filtered through a 21st-century streaming sensibility. It was a nostalgic throwback that felt fresh simply because it was so unashamedly earnest.

At its core, “Perfect” is a narrative ballad chronicling a love story from a wistful, autumnal perspective. Sheeran paints in broad, romantic strokes: dancing in the dark, barefoot on the grass, listening to one’s favorite song. The lyrics are not designed to challenge; they are designed to embrace. When he sings, “I found a love for me,” the simplicity is the point. He avoids the tortured metaphors of a Taylor Swift or the abstract poetry of a Hozier, opting instead for the universal language of a greeting card. This is both the song’s greatest strength and its most glaring weakness. Ed Sheeran - Perfect

So, where does that leave us? Is “Perfect” a great song? To understand “Perfect,” one must understand the moment