I’ll be destroyed.
Heartbroken, Ivy packs. But Poppy—who has been mute for two years—grabs Ivy’s suitcase handle and whispers her first full sentence: “Please don’t go.” Cole realizes his “heartless” act didn’t protect Poppy; it almost cost her the only mother figure she’s known. He races to the bus station in the pouring rain, finds Ivy, and finally breaks. He reveals the truth: The fire was an electrical fault. He did try to save Lila, but the beam fell on her. His scars are from trying to lift it with his bare hands. He’s not heartless—he’s drowning in guilt.
But Willow Creek has a long memory. The townsfolk whisper that Cole started the mill fire. That he was drunk. That he chose to save his business documents over his wife. When Ivy overhears the full, distorted rumor at the local diner, she demands the truth. Cole, terrified of her pity, pushes her away cruelly: “You’re just a summer distraction. You don’t belong here.”